December Reading List

Most of my library reads these days are my endless pursuit of comp titles for my speculative fiction novel. Feel free to share your own struggle for comps, your own success with comps, or your own questions about what the heck comps are, and I’ll commiserate/cheer/answer anything in the comments. 😅

I first read Useless Miracle. From the synopsis on the back, I figured I’d located an ideal potential comp title: also a professor MC with a quirky cast of friends! also an unintended superhero piece with a sense of humor! Unfortunately, I couldn’t really get into this book. The characters seemed sort of distant in an odd combination of snobbish intellectual and inside jokes that are never explained to the reader. There were definitely humorous moments and it’s certainly a fun and offbeat story idea, but the pace was also a bit too slow for my taste. It has mostly 3-star reviews on Goodreads, which feels about right (3.8 stars on Amazon). I suppose I would want a comp title with higher reviews anyway, so we’ll carry onward!

Next, I read The 22 Murders of Madison May, which I greatly enjoyed. It’s a bit more of a sci-fi thriller, as it follows a serial killer traveling through the multiverse to kill all the Madison Mays that rejected him in the supposed pursuit of the parallel universe where the one who truly loves him exists. A reporter, Felicity Staples, ends up caught in the murder/multiverse travel drama in one universe and gets carried along from place to place, hoping to bring the killer to justice. This one has mainly 4-star reviews on Goodreads and a 4.2 on Amazon. If we’re tossing out stars, I would give it a 4.5 (and would have given it a 5 if Felicity and the killer both had more clear motives for their choices). Sadly, not really comparable to my book as my story is certainly not a thriller.

Last, I read The Midnight Bargain. I’d read a pitch of this book on an agent’s page and thought it seemed like a good comp, though I no longer believe so after reading. I loved the story, but it feels more like a coming-of-age high fantasy story while mine features a thirty-something mother in the real world. Beatrice Clayborn lives in a world of sorcery and magic, though women are cut off from reaching their true potential as sorceresses; they’re required upon marriage to wear a collar that limits their powers. Beatrice desires a life that is less the role of traditional wife and mother and more an embrace of her magic, and she forms an expected alliance to try to achieve her dreams.

I’ll continue searching for comps. Some of the likely comps for my book are veering into the realms of urban fantasy and magical realism, which I think are probably the closest labels. A great piece of advice I recently received from an agent, when I told her I was having difficulty labeling my book’s genre beyond “speculative adult fiction”, was to see which books are the closest comp titles. My story has a superhero, though she isn’t a traditional superhero by any means. The story has elements that are similar to Marvel (magical superhuman strength and the ability to pause time, quirky humor, heroes and antiheroes that protect or destroy humanity), others that are more like magical realism (the real-world setting, a mysterious figure in a reflection, a melting mirror, etc.), and others that are more literary (the concerns of young adult cancer patients, mom guilt, familial trauma). If any comp titles come to mind when you see this list of attributes, please let me know. Thank you! ❤️

3 thoughts on “December Reading List

  1. An interesting list. I’m guessing that comp means comparative and the search is to find a published work that allows you to determine the niche that your novel falls into… yes? Anyway, I personally think having a book that defies being put into a category would appeal to a wider audience!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, that’s essentially it! I would love to just say that my novel will appeal to everyone, but I guess I’m not allowed to say that in my query 😅 The agents say it’s to help them picture where it might be shelved at a bookstore, which would ideally lead to how they sell it to publishers. It makes sense, but it’s a tough process to find the “right” ones.

      Like

Leave a reply to wordsandcoffee1 Cancel reply